Skip to main content

Board Game Post Mortem : The Bad


The Theme

I had intended to create an atmosphere of appalled incredulity with capitalists and their dogma and use the chaotic expression of the proponents of free thought, namely anarchist as a tool to force the players to grapple with the crushing, mundane and defeating nature of bureaucratised meritocratic society. Which can be thought of as a long-winded way of saying 'this shit sucks' in reference to the current state of affairs and 'what if it didn't have to be the way it currently is?'  in reference to systems that are more in line with something like anarchism. 
What I actually created in my view is a game in which the system you interact with heavily encourage you to come to the conclusion that both sides are:
  1. Equal, in either or both their viability to organise society
  2. Only cosmetically different, in that they function on the same axis using the same tool for the same tasks.
  3. Rigid, you are unable to alter anything about the side you are on or the other side meaning that part from the choice to compete or not there is no choice of any value to be made.
  4. Competing for the same thing, both sides concern themselves with the same goals, the only difference being simple tribalism that it be your tribe that wins and not the other.
The result of this is if concerned only with what the systems imply or encourage the game's message is one of 'The Enlightened Centrist' who has positioned themselves in the very centre the conflict to declare moral authority by virtue of holding no beliefs. They see their lack of belief as evidence of their superiority as it is impossible to intellectually attack their position as they do not hold one to begin with. I personally very much dislike this as its both counter to what I was attempting to accomplish with the theme of this game and also contrary to my own personal beliefs.

What would have potential save me from making these grave errors in the design of the game systems was al large quantity of interactive and heavily analysed playtesting. As it stats the game has never been run physically as in using the printed cards and board and only a scarce number of times in my own head to check for the game design equivalents of grammatical errors. Such is life in the pandemic. Moving forward I'm committed to playtesting early and frequently by creating as many rough version of systems and assets as possible to prevent this kind of error from coalescing again. By actually experiencing the games I'm am making as they are made, much like a chef tastes their own cooking I hope to gain better insight into my own practise and grow from it without the need for every project to be so far off the mark. Correct the trajectory of the arrow mid-flight as it were, so as to at least hit the target if not get a bullseye.

My final thought to the theme is that even whilst failing in a lot of areas it wasn't conveyed universally enough for my liking it needed to appear on the board and in the rules and in the names of the action the players were taking and not just on the item cards. This was the result of the final part which I shall discuss next so needless to say it is something I will improve upon hereafter.

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

2D Side Scroller : The Final Idea

When the rubber meets the road. The Panda here represents  Covid-19 During the course of recent events, it became clear to me that my time was somewhat limited in this project. As a result, I have elected to go with my first idea, the Dung beetle puzzle game. This should provide me with a decent opportunity to stretch myself in the implementation and iteration of mechanically without requiring nearly as much in terms of asset creation which for this project at least isn't one of the marking criteria anyway.  The Dung Beetle Puzzle Game is changing slightly to just a puzzle game but keeping the core idea of pushing a large ball around as its main mechanic. So the player characters job is to get the ball to its goal and then make their way to the exit of the stage. This gives me a solid and simple foundation to build some hopefully cool puzzles off of without bogging me down in extra systems, which if you refer to my previous ideas was rampant. Even when stating that I have eyes...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Barbican

Enemy at the Gate The Barbican estate in London features a lot of the style of architecture that I wanted to emulate in the art and design project, so for this project, I'm going to try to create my own barbican estate using the real one as the palette. To do this I'm going to create concept art using the barbican as part of a reference sandwich to create unique architecture that should both be evocative of contemporary London, retrofuturist and contain elements meant to subtly guide the player through the area to their goal.
Post a Comment
Read more

Art and Design Exercises : Decontructing Art into Basic Shapes for 3D Modeling, Glastonbury Dam

The Poäng of Art Glastonbury Dam, By Tyler Edlin, can be broken down into one large cube for the central building of the castle with another rotated and reduced for the roof. The wall is comprised of 4 cylinders with cones on top for the rooves. The tunnel section of the wall could be constructed from rectangles and cylinders using the difference boolean. For the details on the turrets themselves such as the wooden beams, I would use rectangles sunken into the surface to create the depth present in the facade. Alot of the surface detail is heavily repeated on a micro-scale and then on a macro-scale so I would probably try to create a detailed wall for example by creating the largest parts first then cut to get the tunnel, then add the rectangles to make up the supports on one small section and copy that across its breadth. Finally, I would then copy the whole thing for the other walls and make any changes that need to be made to distinguish them. using the same technique I would make t...
Post a Comment
Read more